Codeigniter: Separating reads and writes for scaling MySQL

October 23, 2008

Generally websites average a ratio of 9:1 or more for reads:writes for their applications which makes MySQL replication as one of the ways to scale you web application. The simplest configuration is to separate reads and writes with all the reads coming from the slave servers.

MySQL Database replication

We can implement this in codeigniter using database groups. Below is a sample execution.

Create two active groups - one for read and one for write.

File: system/application/config/database.php

$active_group = 'write';
$active_record = TRUE;

$db['read']['hostname'] = 'localhost';
$db['read']['username'] = 'root';
$db['read']['password'] = '';
$db['read']['database'] = 'read_database_name';
$db['read']['dbdriver'] = 'mysql';
$db['read']['dbprefix'] = '';
$db['read']['pconnect'] = TRUE;
$db['read']['db_debug'] = FALSE;
$db['read']['cache_on'] = FALSE;
$db['read']['cachedir'] = '';
$db['read']['char_set'] = 'utf8';
$db['read']['dbcollat'] = 'utf8_general_ci';

$db['write']['hostname'] = 'localhost';
$db['write']['username'] = 'root';
$db['write']['password'] = '';
$db['write']['database'] = 'write_database_name';
$db['write']['dbdriver'] = 'mysql';
$db['write']['dbprefix'] = '';
$db['write']['pconnect'] = TRUE;
$db['write']['db_debug'] = FALSE;
$db['write']['cache_on'] = FALSE;
$db['write']['cachedir'] = '';
$db['write']['char_set'] = 'utf8';
$db['write']['dbcollat'] = 'utf8_general_ci';

Create separate database connections to access read and write databases separately where needed (constructor is generally a good place for this).

$read_db = $this->load->database('read', TRUE);
$write_db = $this->load->database('write', TRUE);

You can now go about running queries in the usual way.

/* For reads */
$query = $read_db->get('table_name');

foreach ($query->result() as $row)
{
    echo $row->title;
}

/* For writes */
$data = array(
        'title' => $title,
        'name' => $name,
        'date' => $date
        );

$write_db->insert('mytable', $data);

In case you want to try this on an application you are already running, you can leave the “default” connection group intact and create only the “read” connection group. Use it where you think you are running read heavy queries.

Old Comments

Stinky Tofu

This is an interesting approach. Just wondering though, if you have a master db that is for writes only and a slave db for reads only, then instead of asking the programmer to specify which database to read/write from/to in their code, why not set it up so that whenever I call $db->insert, $db->update, or $db->delete, then automatically use the master db to perform the write, if I am calling $db->query, then the code should be smart enough to connect to the slave db for the reads. Would this be a safer approach? It would help prevent human error. Curious to find out what you think about this approach.


Sukumar Yethadka

@Stinky Tofu Yes, that would be quite a good approach and can be implemented just by extending the database model. My preference is slightly different though. I like to use fat controllers and thin models (most of the logic is in the controller). Because of this, I have a base model where I have all the commonly used methods defined (different way of CRUD) and all other models just extend from it. This way I don’t need to decide what query goes where everyday but, just at the time of writing the model.


Naren

Very interesting take. Why don’t you create a database helper/extend the database class to abstract away the need to keep track of which DB you’re supposed to write to, and read from.


Brad Proctor

You really need to be careful with this. What happens if you make an insert and the user is redirected to see the results and a select is occurs of what was just inserted, but the the master hasn’t replicated yet. The user sees nothing. To fix this, that select needs to occur on the master.

comments powered by Disqus